ZeroRating conversations are dominating Network Neutrality issues these days, whether it is the FreeBasics controversy in India, Binge On by T-Mobile, or Verizon's recent announcement of a plan similar to AT&T's sponsored data. Here are a few thoughts to consider about ZeroRating and why it makes no sense (to me).
If ISPs Zero Rate content, somebody has to pay for the bandwidth. Suppose the Content provider pays for it. Then there is a pricing problem:
It is not clear to me what the business model is for ZeroRating, where the ISPs make money and provide an Open and Neutral Internet experience for their consumers. Economic issues are really the core of Network Neutrality, and nobody has explained to me how the economic model of ZeroRating remains consistent with Network Neutrality
If ISPs Zero Rate content, somebody has to pay for the bandwidth. Suppose the Content provider pays for it. Then there is a pricing problem:
- ISPs cannot charge the content provider a price above the price they charge consumers. Suppose they charge consumers X per MB of data, and they charge content providers X+Y per MB of data. Then, for sufficient traffic where overheads are accounted for, it is cheaper for content providers to send recharge coupons back directly to the customers who used their services. Long term, pricing above the consumer price is not sustainable.
- ISPs cannot charge the content provider a price below the price they charge consumers. Suppose they charge consumers X per MB of data, and they charge content providers X-Y per MB of data. Then if the plan is truly open, a company like Gigato can come along, buy data in volume and become a virtual ISP. They can funnel traffic to services via their servers (they can remain good guys and not decrypt or store private data), sell the bandwidth to consumers at X-Y/2 and pocket the difference. The ISPs lose out.
- This opens the possibility of vertical integration, where ISPs ZeroRate their own content, and that is extremely bad for competition. Or ISPs ZeroRate only a select group of content providers, for non-transparent reasons (FreeBasics or Binge On "technical" requirements that make the walled gardens implicitly closed), leading to a fractured experience/Internet for their consumers.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteGood points. If ZR is meant for the unconnected, i.e. those with low purchasing power, that's the target group of little interest to advertisers.
ReplyDeleteISPs also lose in the long term by replacing individual customers with with bulk buyers who have higher bargaining power.
Take a look at Mozilla Position
ReplyDeletehttps://blog.lizardwrangler.com/2015/05/06/zero-rating-and-the-open-internet/
https://blog.mozilla.org/netpolicy/2015/05/05/mozilla-view-on-zero-rating/
Hi Anivar,
DeleteAm aware of the Mozilla position. It is a mix of philanthropy and adhering to net neutrality principles (equal rating) and is a good approach. Aircel is making a bet with their equal rated plan that users will convert, and they are not being selective like Reliance (FreeBasics) or T-mobile. Vertical integration is the biggest danger of ISP paid zero rating and we should be watchful there.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteRealistically assuming that ISP can only charge as much as market price to the consumers, it has an incentive to increase market price upto the point where it strangles all revenue out of the Content Provider. Consumers consume zero of paid content as the prices are too high and rely on zero rating.
ReplyDeleteSuch a situation though will not arise practically shows that ISP's have an incentive to increase market prices
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteNowadays, a lot of people are more concerned about their health than anything else. They are more careful in choosing the foods they eat because of the fact that most diseases nowadays involve in the lifestyle of man. Well, some people are also practicing a work-home routine to avoid any accidents that might happen to them when they are outside of their house. But sometimes, some unexpected things really do happen and having a health spending account is the best option that you could get. benefits hot yoga
ReplyDeleteAre we really doing worksite wellness today? In this article, you will learn the difference between worksite wellness and employee health improvement. buy research chemicals online
ReplyDeleteWhile the definition of physical fitness can be a little complex or unclear and the definition of physical fitness can vary, most government health agencies and exercise scientists agree that there are 5 components of physical fitness related to health. These components provide a fairly accurate representation of how fit and healthy the body is as a whole (total or overall fitness). sbarra a terra floor barre
ReplyDeleteRegular dental check-ups are conducive to a great smile and optimum dental health. In addition, regular visits tell a dentist about your general health and whether you might be developing certain diseases like diabetes. Current research states that the health of your mouth is an indication of the condition of your overall bodily health. For instance, when your dental health is up to par, chances are your general health is good as well. Alternatively, if your dental health is poor, there may be underlying problems. Studies show that good oral health can actually prevent specific disease from occurring. Dentists can detect clues to your general health while examining your mouth and gums. safe weight loss products
ReplyDeleteRegular dental check-ups are conducive to a great smile and optimum dental health. In addition, regular visits tell a dentist about your general health and whether you might be developing certain diseases like diabetes. Current research states that the health of your mouth is an indication of the condition of your overall bodily health. For instance, when your dental health is up to par, chances are your general health is good as well. Alternatively, if your dental health is poor, there may be underlying problems. Studies show that good oral health can actually prevent specific disease from occurring. Dentists can detect clues to your general health while examining your mouth and gums. Fildena 100 mg
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHealth coaches are more than your typical physician, nutritionist and psychologist. They do not individually look at your physical, emotional or mental health. Health coaches look at all aspects to ensure you achieve optimal health. They will help make your body and brain to feel better. peritol pill
ReplyDeleteI really wanted to send a quick word in order to thank you for all of the remarkable points you are giving out here. My time consuming internet look up has now been rewarded with reliable details to write about with my friends and family. I would repeat that most of us site visitors actually are very much lucky to be in a notable site with very many awesome people with very beneficial points. I feel truly blessed to have discovered the website page and look forward to really more excellent minutes reading here. Thanks again for everything. 918kiss pussy888 android
ReplyDeleteHealth has always been a great deal for most people. When it comes to fitness, they have tried different ways, techniques, equipment, and technology just to be fit and healthy. 3/4 compression pants
ReplyDeleteThanks for the good critique. Me and my friend were just preparing to do some research about this. We got a book from our area library but I think I’ve learned more from this post. I am very glad to see such excellent info being shared freely out there.. 토토사이트
ReplyDeleteThis is really interesting, You’re a highly trained writer. I’ve joined with your feed and furthermore , count on witnessing the very good write-ups. Additionally, I’ve shared your websites with our social networks. 파워볼사이트
ReplyDeleteKnowing the best foods to feed our children is a challenge as we try to navigate the pervasive misinformation we are fed from every direction. If we are to stem the tide of increasing sickness in our society and among our kids then we need to understand some important nutrition fundamentals and key health issues so we can support our children in achieving great health that will last a lifetime. This article reveals the myths and truths about the best first foods for baby. obstructive sleep apnea
ReplyDeleteI like this site very much, Its a very nice position to read and receive info . 토토커뮤니티
ReplyDeleteA vast difference exists between the words health and wellness. While most people consider these words to convey similar meanings, their definitions vary considerably. Health, according to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, is defined as, "the condition of being sound in body, mind, or spirit; especially freedom from physical disease or pain." More simply put, health is a conditional state. Best Tasting Matcha
ReplyDeleteI like this site very much, Its a very nice position to read and receive info . 먹튀검증
ReplyDeleteWith the Internet booming, health insurance being sold has changed and conformed to a great advantage to the consumers. Today you can easily avail of quotes from several suppliers without the need to leave your desk or the cost of several phone calls. This big savings in time made possible in this modern way of obtaining quotes have eliminated old systems as anybody can access the Internet and consequently benefit from it not only through competitive quotes but also in making their choices of suppliers even wider. So when you plan to buy insurance, maximize this advantage. one shot keto reviews
ReplyDeleteThere is a need to increase the number of insured people in India. Taking an effective step in this regard, the health insurance companies have formulated several affordable health plans. The basic health insurance plays a major role in today's lifestyle. They become a source of great comfort by offering a hassle free way to seek health security. While purchasing a policy, the biggest concern for people is the insurance cost. But in that one must not overlook the reputation of the insurer. You must prefer a trusted name like Apollo Munich that can assure best medical services. Executive Medical Director Andrea Natale
ReplyDeleteIt is not enough to know about healthy food or exercise. It is not adequate to focus on your body and forget about other aspects. Health is about the combination of all important factors. pillule pour bander
ReplyDeleteHealth coaches are more than your typical physician, nutritionist and psychologist. They do not individually look at your physical, emotional or mental health. Health coaches look at all aspects to ensure you achieve optimal health. They will help make your body and brain to feel better. Marijuana online for sale with credit card and PayPal
ReplyDeleteNowadays, a lot of people are more concerned about their pakistanhub1 than anything else. They are more careful in choosing the foods they eat because of the fact that most diseases nowadays involve in the lifestyle of man. Well, some people are also practicing a work-home routine to avoid any accidents that might happen to them when they are outside of their house. But sometimes, some unexpected things really do happen and having a health spending account is the best option that you could get.
ReplyDeleteWe know that marijuana/pot/weed is illegal. We learned in high school that it's a gateway drug. Do you remember anything else about it? Or why they said it's bad for you? alpine carts
ReplyDeleteits been long since i saw a post that's so educative and informational. i will make sure to share this my facebook group. you can also view contents on our websites below.
ReplyDeleteFrench Bulldog Puppies For Sale
French Bulldog Breeders
French Bulldog Puppies For Sale Near Me
French Bulldog Puppies For adoption
French Bulldog Puppies
Blue French Bulldog Puppies
it's so refreshing to see a post that talks straight to the point. thanks so much for writing about this it has really helped me with building my experience. thanks a lot
ReplyDeletesiberian husky puppies for sale near me
Siberian Husky puppies
Siberian Husky puppies for adoption
Siberian Husky puppies breeders near me
white Siberian Husky puppies
Westfield Health has been supplying consumers in the UK with secure health insurance products for well over 90 years. They currently have in excess of 300,000 policyholders who have some form of health insurance coverage with them. Westfield Health offer health insurance products to individuals and their families, businesses and their employees, and they even offer an intermediary service whereby any healthcare intermediary is able to offer Westfield Health's products to their clients. Internal Medicine
ReplyDeleteNon-profit hospitals are mandated by the Federal Government to undertake a 'community needs health assessment.' This undertaking looks at the most pressing health needs in the area served by the hospital(s). In my county, several hospitals and the county health agency undertook this charge. The data supply gives a good indication where dollars need to be spent to provide the services most needed. Dilator for athletes
ReplyDeleteminiature dachshund Puppies For Sale Near Me
ReplyDeletecheap Dachshund Puppies For adoption
Dapple dachshund Puppies For Sale Near Me
Dachshund Puppies For Adoption
Regular dental check-ups are conducive to a great smile and optimum dental health. In addition, regular visits tell a dentist about your general health and whether you might be developing certain diseases like diabetes. Current research states that the health of your mouth is an indication of the condition of your overall bodily health. For instance, when your dental health is up to par, chances are your general health is good as well. Alternatively, if your dental health is poor, there may be underlying problems. Studies show that good oral health can actually prevent specific disease from occurring. Dentists can detect clues to your general health while examining your mouth and gums. Dentist
ReplyDeleteRegular dental check-ups are conducive to a great smile and optimum dental health. In addition, regular visits tell a dentist about your general health and whether you might be developing certain diseases like diabetes. Current research states that the health of your mouth is an indication of the condition of your overall bodily health. For instance, when your dental health is up to par, chances are your general health is good as well. Alternatively, if your dental health is poor, there may be underlying problems. Studies show that good oral health can actually prevent specific disease from occurring. Dentists can detect clues to your general health while examining your mouth and gums. Full mouth dental implants
ReplyDeleteMany thanks for your kind invitation. I’ll join you.
ReplyDeleteWould you like to play cards?
Come to the party with me, please.
See you soon...
เครดิตฟรี
เล่นบาคาร่า
คาสิโนออนไลน์
เล่นบาคาร่า
The list of raw foods included on the raw food diet includes fruits, vegetables, sprouts, and even a few processed food items such as kimchee and raw nut butter. These foods are great by themselves and can be combined to create scrumptious meals. 스포츠토토먹튀검증
ReplyDeleteRemarkable! Its truly remarkable post, I have got much clear idea on the topic of from this article.
ReplyDeletemy webpage … Buy Vyvanse 70mg Online Overnight
Many hospital groups and physician provider groups do not realize how beneficial their county health department can be to their providing of quality health services. This article focuses on the benefits of working with your local health departments in keeping your patients healthy through excellent prevention approaches. www.healthnezz.com
ReplyDeleteThe provision of health sanitation is a key development intervention - without it, ill health dominates a life without dignity. Simply having access to sanitation increases health, well-being and economic productivity. Inadequate sanitation impacts individuals, households, communities and countries. Large Essential Oil Diffuser
ReplyDeleteIllness for non-work related injuries can be financially devastating. Insurance keeps you protected against disastrous health care expenses and lost wages. There are enormous health insurance plans available day-to-day, the health insurance cost and its benefits vary from one plans to another. Before enrolling for a health insurance, an individual should consult with the insurance agencies, read the policy to get the complete information about the benefits and costs and also the way the plan works. Best Essential oil diffuser
ReplyDeleteKnowing the best foods to feed our children is a challenge as we try to navigate the pervasive misinformation we are fed from every direction. If we are to stem the tide of increasing sickness in our society and among our kids then we need to understand some important nutrition fundamentals and key health issues so we can support our children in achieving great throughout the article I will be going to do the sign up in about 20 minutes after I get finished that will last a lifetime. This article reveals the myths and truths about the best first foods for baby.
ReplyDeleteMany people acquire depersonalization disorder by smoking marijuana. In this article I want to talk about how marijuana use is related to depersonalization. I want to clarify the relationship between marijuana and depersonalization. There is a lot of confusion about marijuana-induced depersonalization, and whether or not it is different from non-marijuana induced depersonalization. I also want to show you what you can do to totally eliminate marijuana-induced depersonalization and regain a healthy sense of self. best-mario-carts-online
ReplyDeleteIt is not enough to know about healthy food or exercise. It is not adequate to focus on your body and forget about other aspects. Health is about the combination of all important factors. test enanthate
ReplyDeleteThe cost for ObamaCare has many Americans trying to understand how we can foot the bill. It will connect millions more Americans to a sickness industry gone wild. hgh for sale
ReplyDeleteTotal health care for the elderly, unlike individual healthcare for the average person, often demands non-financial resources like personal attention, commitment of time, and dedication. For elderly health care to be effective, keep in mind that money alone may not help even though there's a place for individual health coverage with help of elderly health insurance. best place to buy real hgh online
ReplyDeleteHey. Very nice web site!! Man .. Excellent .. Superb .. I’ll bookmark your website and take the feeds also…I am glad to locate numerous helpful information here in the article. Thanks for sharing. Monument signs
ReplyDeleteTypically, students who possess an interest in participating in herbal studies at one of several herbal medicine schools should have attained some education in physiology and/or anatomy prior to enrollment. This is important, as it lends to the student's ability to better understand the philosophy and theories behind herbal how to increase sex time without medicine
ReplyDeletetherapies.
What is good mental health? We are all more or less mentally healthy, and this usually varies through our lives especially as we deal with difficult life events, change and so on. Whether we call this psychological wellbeing, happiness, contentment, positive mindset, all these terms relate to good mental health. Hypnotherapy Adelaide
ReplyDeletePresident Barack Obama signed the bill for Health Care Reform on March 23, 2010. The bill will not only change the way Americans pay for health care, but also how they pay for insurance and utilize America's health brokers. blepharoplasty before and after
ReplyDeleteTypically, students who possess an interest in participating in herbal studies at one of several herbal Viagra schools should have attained some education in physiology and/or anatomy prior to enrollment. This is important, as it lends to the student's ability to better understand the philosophy and theories behind herbal medicine therapies.
ReplyDeleteToday there are more than 100 chest infection medicine conditions that can be helped with holistic medicine, including migraines, chronic fatigue syndrome, and even cancer. Making a career in this field definitely seem to be very promising as the demand of holistic medicine doctors are even expected to grow more in the next few years.
ReplyDeleteI have been surfing online more than three working hours today, however I never found any kind of interesting document like your own. It is quite worth enough to me. Personally, if all web owners and blog writers created great articles as you did, the internet will be a lot more useful than previously. situs judi slot online
ReplyDeleteWhy are Americans so worked up about health care reform? Statements such as "don't touch my Medicare" or "everyone should have access to state of the art health care irrespective of cost" are in my opinion uninformed and visceral responses that indicate a poor understanding of our health care system's history, its current and future resources and the funding challenges that America faces going forward. While we all wonder how the health care system has reached what some refer to as a crisis stage. Let's try to take some of the emotion out of the debate by briefly examining how diarrhea medicine care in this country emerged and how that has formed our thinking and culture about health care. With that as a foundation let's look at the pros and cons of the Obama administration health care reform proposals and let's look at the concepts put forth by the Republicans?
ReplyDeleteRight now it appears like Drupal is the preferred blogging platform available right now. (from what I’ve read) Is that what you’re using on your blog? buy injectable steroids online
ReplyDeletePretty nice post, I was doing a google search and your site came up for short sales in Altamonte Springs, FL but anyway, I have thoroughly enjoyed reading it, keep it up! 먹튀검증
ReplyDeleteIt is very rare these days to find websites that provide info someone is looking for. I am glad to see that your website share valued information that can help to many readers. nice one and keep writing! seo dan backlink
ReplyDeleteAwesome material you fellas got these. I actually like the theme for the website along with how you organized a person who. It’s a marvelous job For certain i will come back and check out you out sometime. 토토사이트 순위
ReplyDeleteA degree in natural viagra tablet use has a bit of everything. While western medicine focuses on the organs and systems of the body individually, alternative medicine focuses on the entire human being from the patient's internal condition to the emotional balance and state of mind.
ReplyDeleteIn the last decade it has been noticed that alternative viagra capsule is getting more and more popular all over US and the rest of the world. Have you ever considered consulting an alternative medical practitioner? Let's see the pro and cons of alternative medicine.
ReplyDeleteI am glad to be a visitor of this utter website ! , appreciate it for this rare info ! . 군산출장안마
ReplyDeleteWow Da weiss man, wo es hingehen muss Viele Grüsse Moni 광주출장안마
ReplyDeleteI am just commenting to make you be aware of what a brilliant encounter my friend’s girl enjoyed studying your web site. She noticed several things, including what it’s like to have an ideal coaching style to have men and women with no trouble master a variety of complicated subject areas. You undoubtedly did more than readers’ expectations. Thank you for distributing these warm and friendly, dependable, edifying and unique guidance on that topic to Ethel. 대전출장안마
ReplyDeleteWhere is your small business at now? Do you have a charted plan? Do you get great advise? This article highlights 10 points that will assist the small business mindset of each and every business owner that reads it. prize bond list
ReplyDeleteWhat is good food for irritable bowel syndrome? What is bad food for irritable bowel syndrome? Why does it even matter? By answering these questions properly you are reinforcing your lifestyle and protecting your happiness even further with knowledge and tools at your disposal for reinforcement for overall better living. paystub generator
ReplyDeleteHello there! I simply want to offer you a huge thumbs up for the excellent information you’ve got here on this post. I’ll be coming back to your web site for more soon. Maybe i can show you about the online game might you will be interesting if you visit my website at Aztec Online
ReplyDeleteNatural health remedy actually holds a simple and effective solution to improving health. No matter how well people have built their professional work credentials, those people still know very little about how the human body works. Buy Klonopin online
ReplyDeletei frequent hair salons because i always want to keep my hair in top shape:: StreamComplet
ReplyDeletei frequent hair salons because i always want to keep my hair in top shape:: 토토사이트
ReplyDeleteThis can be a remarkably amazing powerful resource that you’re offering and you simply provide it away cost-free!! I comparable to discovering websites ones comprehend the particular importance of supplying you with a excellent learning resource for zero cost. We truly dearly loved examining these pages. Appreciate it! pkv games apk
ReplyDeleteThe the next time I read a weblog, I hope that this doesnt disappoint me up to this one. I am talking about, I know it was my substitute for read, but I just thought youd have something intriguing to state. All I hear is usually a few whining about something that you could fix should you werent too busy seeking attention. Focused on Dutch government
ReplyDeleteThis can be a remarkably amazing powerful resource that you’re offering and you simply provide it away cost-free!! I comparable to discovering websites ones comprehend the particular importance of supplying you with a excellent learning resource for zero cost. We truly dearly loved examining these pages. Appreciate it! concealed handgun license classes
ReplyDeleteHealth insurance intends to provide financial security during the time of illness of injury. Florida enjoys good health status as compared to many other states in the US; however, there are lots of Floridians who still live without any health insurance policy to provide coverage. genetic test
ReplyDeleteYou produced some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the problem and discovered most people may go along with along with your web site. 해외축구중계
ReplyDeleteJust about all I can point out is, I don’t know what to comment! Except certainly, for the wonderful tips which are shared with this blog. I will think of a million fun strategies to read the reports on this site. I’m sure I will at last make a move using your tips on those things I could never have been able to touch alone. You had been so innovative to let me be one of those to benefit from your useful information. Please know how much I am thankful. สล็อต
ReplyDeleteYou seem to be very professional in the way you write.*”~*~ ufabet เข้าสู่ระบบ
ReplyDeleteHealth coaches are more than your typical physician, nutritionist and psychologist. They do not individually look at your physical, emotional or mental health. Health coaches look at all aspects to ensure you achieve optimal health. They will help make your body and brain to feel better. anavar buy
ReplyDeleteGood aftie” i am a blogger too. and i can see that you are a nice blogger too, maderotherapy abu dhabi
ReplyDeleteYou lost me, buddy. I mean, I assume I get what youre declaring. I have an understanding of what you’re saying, but you just seem to have forgotten about that you’ll find some other individuals within the world who view this matter for what it actually is and may perhaps not agree with you. You may be turning away many of men and women who may have been supporters of your blog site. 링크 빌딩
ReplyDeletePreviously you must have highly effective web business strategies get you started of getting into topics suitable for their web-based organization. educational backlink massal
ReplyDeletewhen we do our home renovation, we always look for new home styles and designs on the internet for some great ideas. 대출
ReplyDeleteHello – I must say, I’m impressed with your site. I had no trouble navigating through all the tabs and information was very easy to access. I found what I wanted in no time at all. Pretty awesome. Would appreciate it if you add forums or something, it would be a perfect way for your clients to interact. Great job 토토검증사이트
ReplyDeleteThe shoe features a lightweight design that makes it comfortable for running or any other activity that requires agility.The Nike Zoom Pegasus is another Nike sport shoe that has gained popularity among athletes. UGGThe shoe features a sleek design and provides excellent support and cushioning for the feet. It is suitable for running on different terrains, making it an ideal choice for outdoor activities.Nike also has a range of sport shoes designed specifically for basketball players. The Nike LeBron James shoes are a popular choice among basketball enthusiasts. The shoes provide excellent grip on the court, making it easiefor players to make quick movements.Apart from basketball,
ReplyDelete